Complimentary Board E-Learning Platform access extended until the end of 2021 Posted by: Anastasia Politiuk, 10:11 Blog Entry. NAI offers a variety of rugged embedded boards - both Multifunction IO Cards & Single Board Computers in OpenVPX, cPCI, VME and PCI/PCIe form factors. When combined with our smart function modules they have the ability to meet a wide range of complex and time-critical sense and response requirements for I/O-intensive, mission-critical applications.
Some files may open up directly by clicking the link. Depending on your system and browser associations, you may need to right-click and ‘save as..’ to your computer first and then open up the file locally from your computer. Help build this resource. Send in your program ideas to INFO@reslife.net.
Oh Deer…Finals
When Roommates Become Spooky
Sexual Assault: What you need to know and how to prevent it
For Math Lovers – Tau vs. Pi
Monopoly
Spring Break 101 with Stewie Griffin
Spring Semester Study Support
Clean Up After Yourself with a Harry Potter Theme
Have Stress? Mischief Managed
Happy Holidays! End of Year Educational Board
Illustrations of Ireland
Santa Claus Around the World
Who Would Win?
Social Justice and Harry Potter
November is Diabetes Awareness Month
Don’t be a Monster of a Roommate
No Shave November
What are you thankful for?
The C’s of Sex: Consent and Contraception
How to Survive Your Rookie Year in College (with football theme)
Welcome Board for Start of Year
Inspirational Quote Series
Recycling Education via a fun Marble Run
Finals Week Advice from your Profs
I’ll Remember You (for end of year closure)
Transgender Education
Super Smash Brothers
Suicide Support for Floor Residents (in the event of a suicide)
St. Patty’s Day Quotes
Take My Heart and Let’s Never Part
Diversity, Inclusion and Dr. Seuss
Five Tips and Tricks to Get Beach Body Ready
Sliding into a new year
HeForShe Campaign
Finals Survival: A guide to making the grade
For November – National Novel Writing Month
Black Friday Shopping Tips
Before you swipe right … and other relationship advice
Recycling
A Doctor Who inspired with the names of on campus resources
Adderall
Harry Potter Floor Theme
Affordable Care Act
A Cup of Coffee Shared with a Friend is Happiness
Recycling Facts
Halloween Horror Movies
Trick or Treat…Halloween Safe Sex Bulletin Board
Highlight how your residents are getting involved on campus!
10 Things Men Can Do To Prevent Sexual Violence
Harry Potter – Total Floor Theme
Disney Actually Does Teach Things
How To Be A Hoot of A Roommate
Campus Resources
Mental Awareness
The Ultimate History of Nintendo
Book Share: Take a Book … Leave a Book
Job Search Tips
Meditate Away
Read Across America
Storm Safety
Thank you for smoking
Need Academic Support?
The Hobbit Finals Board
St. Patty’s Day
The Internet and You
Ireland
Black History Month
Valentines Day
Winter Survival Kit
LGBTQ – Equality
Peanuts/Snoopy
Harry Potter
90’s Theme – The Rugrats
YouTube Roulette
Valentine’s Day
Unconventional Maps
Twitter Door Tag
Ocean Gyres
Halloween
Tips for a Good Start with your College Classes
Stop Smoking
Stress Management
Patenting an Invention
Staying Healthy: Decreasing the Chances of Getting or Spreading the Cold or Flu
Are You Being Safe With Social Media?
Who are You?
Think Before You Speak
Take the Pledge: the Last Text
Girl Code Bulletin Board
February is Body Awareness Month
March into Nutrition
Twister Bulletin Board & Door Tag Idea
Star 3D Door Decoration and Program
Woods Theme Door Decoration and Bulletin Board
“Where Are You From?” Door Decoration and Bulletin Board Idea
Puzzle Piece Welcome Sign, Bulletin Board, and Door Tag
Campus Life Bulletin Board
“Caution” Welcome Sign and Bulletin Board
Welcome Board in Many Languages
The Roommate Theory
College Survival 101
Sliding into a new year
Shake things up in 2013
Rape Culture
New Year Traditions from Around the World
2013 Movies to Watch
Little Mermaid Bulletin Board
In and Out Board
Domestic Violence Board
Hello Kitty Bulletin Board
Up Inspiration Bulletin Board
Find Me: Where’s Waldo?
Are you Being Safe on Facebook?
Christmas Tree Bulletin Board
Applications for iPhones and Androids: Enhance Success in College
Masculinity bulletin board and educational program idea
Elections Matter: The Importance of Voting
“Don’t Get Angry” Angry Bird Bulletin Board: Stress Management Techniques & Tips
The Art of Napping
Fortune Cookie Handout
Breast Cancer Awareness Program & Save the TaTas Bulletin Board
Arabian Nights
Copy of TedTalks
Bulletin Board idea to Prevent Vandalism
Up! Adventure is out there!
Skittles
The Nightmare Before Christmas
What’s your RA role in college?
Thank you for Smoking
Zodiac Signs
National Kite Month
April Showers Test Taking Tips
Meditate Away!
Earth Day / Earth Month
Earning the Grade
Wellness & Zombies
A Helping Hand: A College Student’s Guide to Masturbating
Twitter Bulletin Board
Baseball Trivia
The Office Bulletin Board
Secrets
Storm Safety
Random Acts of Kindness
Museums
Hunger Games Academic Board
Angry Birds on Duty Board
2012: The Last Year?!!!
Black History Month: Inventors
Black History Month Jeopardy!
Dating Season
Evolution
February is Heart Disease Awareness Month
Get More Out of Google: Tips & Tricks for Research
Cool Images from the Hubble Telescope
Job Search Tips Bulletin Board
National Pi Day
V-Day
Practicing Civility, Promoting Respect
Idaho’s Native American Tribes
Jedi or Sith Bulletin Board
Dig Into Your Studies!
Duck Pond Bulletin Board
Tennis Season
Popcorn Reminders: Unique Idea to Share Important Information with Students
Having a Great Second Semester / How to Survive Spring Semester
Welcome Home Bulletin Board
Welcome Back / Spring Break Countdown Board
Tis the Season
Words to Live By
Oceania Fun Facts
It’s Harvest Time in Tennessee
How to Pass Tests
2011 Obsessions
2011: The Year in Review
Staff Duty Board, Baseball Theme
Staff Duty Board, Sea Theme
Welcome Board: About Your RA & What Would You do with $1,000,000?!
Who is Touring Paris? Staff Duty Board
Get to know your RA
All about your RA
What Did You Do This Summer?
Puzzle Pieces
Words with Friends Game
Because Money Doesn’t Grow on Trees
Crossword Puzzle with Information about things to do around the campus
Life Lessons Through Disney
Veggies Facts & Myths
Best Inventions of 2011
“All Our Ovaries” Ovarian Health Bulletin Board & Program
18 Health Tricks to Teach Your Body
National Fire Prevention Week
How Video Games Become Addictive
Halloween Variety Bulletin Board
Halloween Costume Party Bulletin Board
Halloween Facts Bulletin Board
Staying Safe at a Halloween Party
Breast Cancer Awareness
The Fire Fighter Challenge
October is National Letter Writing Week
“Oh the Places You’ll Go”
Tweet Interactive Board
Fall into Good Health
Get to Know You…
Get Involved
What is the QR Code?
Avoid the freshman 15
Nutrition: Back to the Basics: The Food Pyramid
Branch Out
Alcohol Awareness
Top Ten Boxing Matches of All Time
Where is your RA?
Keeping one another safe; Texting-free Driving
Where’s Waldo? Welcome Bulletin Board
The RA Office
Micro Expressions: Lie to Me…
Worst Case Survival Scenarios
Get A Summer Job
Funny and Interesting Phobias
Classical Music
Ted Talks
Charlie Sheen’s Guide to Healthy Interactions
Children’s Book Week
Tourette Syndrome
Diversity in Hollywood
History behind St. Patrick’s Day, Shamrocks, and why we celebrate it
Cosmetology
Single or Taken
Hypertension Medications
How to Break Up with Someone
Diversity
Black History Month
Academy Awards
1990s vs. Now
Top Ten Most Disturbing Books
Beating Winter Boredom
Seasonal Affective Disorder: How to Beat the Winter Blues
Spring Break
Zombie Survival
Promoting Community Involvement/Volunteerism
Alcohol – True or False?
Banish Belly Fat
target=_blank>New Year’s Resolutions
Facts About Religion
Creative Dating
Beauty
Healthy Exams
Micro Lending
Shocking Side Effects of Aderall
Alcohol Myths: True or False
Alcohol Survey
Alcohol Safety: Did you know?
Did You Know?
Seasonal Affective Disorder
Emotional Intelligence
November is Movember
No Shave November Bulletin Board
Computer Vision Syndrome (CVS)
Halloween
He’s Just Not That Into You
Procrastination
Testicular Cancer
Study for Exams Twilight Style!
Inside Scoop – Focus on U of Texas, Austin
Branch Out
Time Wasters and Time Management
Tips for Being A Successful Student Leader
Happy Kitchens and Baths
Things I Have Learned Since My Freshman Year…
Keeping Safe on Campus
Success Tips for Students for Starting the Year
Facebook: Privacy and Professionalism
GLBT Resources
Family Tree
Reduce, Reuse, Recycle
Earth Day
Sun Safety Tips
Game Corner
Zombies
Anxiety
Micro-Lending
Myths about Sharks
The College Disease Guide
Body Language…the good, the bad, and the giveaways…
Famous Female Inventors (March is Women’s History Month)
Amazing Inventions of 2009
Top 10 Lessons for Surviving a Zombie Attack1980 Olympic Hockey Gold Medal
History of the Lego
Why do Men Have Nipples…and other Senseless Information Everyone Needs to Know…
Zombie Apocalypse Basics
Safe Sex
February 28 is Public Sleeping Day
Spring Break: Where to go, top 10 fun things, and safety tips
Fishing for Success
How to say “I Love you” in 30 Different Languages
Tips for Keeping New Years Resolutions
Healthy Relationships: Can you feel the Love?
Staying Warm in Winter
“Who Would Win in a Fight?”
January is Clean Up Your Computer Month
Christmas Movies
Staying Healthy Ninja Style
How to be Awesome!
The “How To” on Skimming, Scanning and Quick Reading for College
Festivus
Boost Brain Power
Highway to Success: Making College Count
The Health Benefits of Humor and Laughter
Princess Wellness
Remembrance Week/Remembering Veterans
H1N1 Flu and You
How “Well” are you?
Lessons Learned from textsfromlastnight.com
Myers Briggs Type Indicator
Have an Issue? Grab a Tissue
“I got a strange disease…”
Coal, Electricity and Conservation
Dinosaurs
Laundry Room Etiquette 101
Halloween Feeling Board
Dr. House’s Tips for Disease Prevention and Treatment
Ramen Noodle Recipes
Haunted Houses
GLBT Awareness Month – (Is in October!)
Alcohol
Abstinence
The World As a Village
Money Management
Sex Fun Facts
Diversity on the Floor
Things to do in Washington, DC
Star Wars
Batman
Zodiac
History of the Condom
April is…Organ Donation Month
Speed Reading
Verbal Abuse
Spread the Word to End the Word
Save Darfur
Take Perfect Pictures
Birth Control
Religion Overview
The Aids Memorial Quilt
Go Red for Women: Heart Disease and Stroke
Caffeine
Recycling
1 sheep…2 sheep – about sleep
Bulletin Board for Luau Themed Floor: STDs
Why Do We Care When Celebrities Die?
February is…
Ten Easy Ways to Go Green
Children’s Book Week
A New President…A New Cabinet
Pick Up Lines for Valentines Day
Some of the Top Ten Things in 2008
Why do you drink?/Alternative Activities to Alcohol Consumption
The Benefits of Chocolate
The Ten Commandments of Good Roommate Relationships
Perfectionism
Brighten Up Your Life
Amazing Women
Twilight
Show Your Friends You Care
Body Image and Advertising
Winter Theme: All My Friends are Flakes
Praxis 1 Preparation Tips
Save The Environment While Saving Money
Depression and Suicide Bulletin Board
December (Finals Survival Bulletin Board)
Carebears
“Fish or No Fish” Board
Death of Celebrities
Chuck Norris for President
World Poverty
Thanksgiving
Novembeard
An RA is…
Fact or Fiction: Hollywood Life Stories
Halloween Theme – The Horrors of Tooth Decay
Day of the Dead
Recycle Mania
Halloween
Don’t Fall Apart … Smile
Halloween
October is Italian Heritage Month
How to Avoid Plagiarism
Surviving College: 101
Roommate Conflicts: Negotiation Strategies for Apartment Issues
The Roommate Fairy Tale
Room Decorating Ideas
An RA Is…
Killer Hurricanes
Make Your Own Make Up
The End of the Year in Pictures
Information About Signing a Lease
Pick Up Lines
Dr. Seuss’s Tips for Academic Success
Relocating for the Summer, Tips for Students
Vegan/Vegetarian Eating
Conserving Resources
Sudoku
Women’s History Milestones
Sexual Awareness A to Z
St. Patty’s Day
Heart Disease with a Valentines Day Spin
Eating Disorders
Winter Driving Tips
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
St. Patty’s Day
Pickup Lines for Valentines Day
Black History Month
Laundry Tips and Tricks
How to Be a Good Roommate
Famous Resident Assistants
Black History Month
Beating the Winter Blues
Pelvic Exams
How to Prevent Flu
Compromise
Zodiac
Console Evolution
Fun Facts About Language
How to Conserve Resources
Spartan Wellness
Nursing Comics
Breast Cancer
Controller Evolution
Top Ten Speeches of the 20th Century
Harry Potter and Halloween
Halloween
Recycle and Re-Use
Body Art
It’s Not All Black and White: Diversity and Discrimination
Self Defense
How to Tie a Tie
The Meaning and Psychology of Color
Optical Illusions
Celebrating Diversity
Reasons to Celebrate in May
Let’s Talk About Sex
Earth Day
April is…
Best April Fools Day Pranks
Identity Theft
Transformers
Safe Sex ABC’s
Autism Awareness
March Movie Madness
Braille Reading and Writing for the Visually Impaired
Earth Day
Myth Busters
How are you feeling?
The Meaning of Dreams
President’s Day
Eating Healthy in the Halls
How to Build A Snowman
Black History Timeline
Zodiac
Dorm vs. Residence Hall. Bulletin Board for Marketing Room Selection
A New Look at Facebook
Time Management
Academic Dishonesty
Eating Disorders
Superhero Residents
Finals Week Preparation Guide
Christmas
Interactive Bulletin Boards and Other Quick Ideas
Hazing
I Saw You on Facebook
Study Skills
Poverty
Movies
Learn to Knit and Crochet
Improve Your Listening Skills
Facebook: Are You Part of the Phenomenon?
Facebook
Reading and Marking Text Books
Add Some Spice to your Dating Life
Food Delivered Fast
Residence Hall Cooking
Learning Styles
Your On-Line Profile…Is Someone Looking Over Your Shoulder?
Bathroom Etiquette for Men
How to Handle a Drunk or Other Drug-Affected Person
Mixed Messages. How Much is One Drink?
Survival Tips for Transitioning to College
The Da Vinci Code
The Fruit of the Spirit
Olympic Facts
Test Anxiety
“Sleep…Gotta Earn It”: Final Exam Tips
Water Conservation
Portion Distortion
Unsung American Hero
Easter
Chuck Norris — Real American Hero
Women’s History Month
You’re my Favorite Mistake
Sexually Transmitted Diseases
Task and Time Management
Ride Share
Staying Healthy in the Winter
How to Lose A Grade in 10 Weeks
How to do Laundry
February…The Multi Faceted Month
President’s Day: Meet The Presidents
African American Inventions
New Year’s Resolutions
New Years Resolutions
You Are the Missing Piece: Information for RA Selection Recruitment
National Pie Day
Kickstart your Creativity
Improve Your Gas Mileage
Effective Note Taking
Conflict
Cold vs. Flu
Alcohol
American Indian Heritage Month
Breast Cancer Awareness
National Chocolate Day
Helping Someone With Alcohol Poisoning
Celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month
College Student Mental Health
Spotlight Bulletin Board for Start of Academic Year
Indoor Tanning
Kosher Kitchen
Emotional Intelligence
GLBT Information
Focus on Australia: Anzac Day
Juggling
St. Patrick’s Day History and Traditions
St. Patty’s Day and Sex Education: Getting Lucky Tonight
St. Patty’s Day
Dress for Success for Women
Dress for Success for Men
A few facts about African Americans in Major League Baseball
Eat Healthy and Stay Active over the Holidays
Getting a Good Night’s Sleep
How to Iron a Dress Shirt
Emotional Abuse
Insomnia
The Origin of Common Sayings
Shoot for the Stars
Stress Management
Creative Dating Ideas
Chinese Zodiac
Donate Blood
Seasonal Affective Disorder
Skin Care
Vegetarian Diet
Halloween History and Facts
Daylight Savings Time
Great American Smoke Out
Pat on the Back
Credit Cards
World Series History
Today’s Trivia
Cooking Down Under
Huffing
Brazil
Body Art
New Zealand
Hanukkuh
Fat and Cholesterol
Depression
Let’s Get Physical
Organ Donation
Kwanza
Breast Cancer
AIDS HIV
Self-Injury
Maintain a Healthy Weight
For a Healthy Heart … Watch the Salt
Eating Well … Understanding the Food Pyramid
Transitioning to College
Spring Break Safety
Valentine’s Day
Black History Month
Eating Disorders
Halloween
Study Skills
Safety
Fire Safety
Alcohol
Sexual Assault, Acquaintance Rape and Healthy Relationships…
Final Exam Survivor: Outwit, Outstudy, Outlast…
Testicular Cancer – Chipmunks
Testicular Cancer – High Risk Alert
Testicular Cancer – On the Bright Side
Testicular Cancer – Functions of the Testicle
Testicular Cancer – Self Exam
Testicular Cancer – Overview
Testicular Cancer – The Size of your Balls
Testicular Cancer – Bulletin Board
Testicular Cancer – It Can Happen To You
Celebrating Women’s History Month
- STMicroelectronics' STM32 family of 32-bit ARM Cortex-M core-based microcontrollers is supported by a wide range of software integrated development environments (IDEs) with C, C, Pascal and JAVA support and debuggers from STMicroelectronics and major 3rd-parties (free versions are available) that are complemented by tools from ST allowing to configure and initialize the MCU or monitor its.
- Learning boards — digital or analog white boards used to visually display key processes, measures, and improvement tests at the unit level — are essential in promoting operational transparency because they offer a way for people to observe the learning process in action.
The challenge of leading innovation is bringing about a sea change in corporate governance. Boards, once the dependably cautious voices urging management to mitigate risk, are increasingly calling for breakthrough innovation in the scramble for competitive advantage. We see this shift playing out across industries—notably at such companies as Ford, Coca-Cola, Nestlé, and Unilever, which are all struggling to address slowing sales in their core businesses.
Embracing innovation and its inherent risks requires that boards and senior management develop new ways of working together. As Mark Ganz, the CEO of Cambia Health Solutions—a company at the forefront of innovation in the health care space—told us, board meetings no longer consist of PowerPoint presentations by management followed by a few perfunctory questions from the board. “The model has changed,” he explained. “We now bring the board ideas that are not fully baked and say, ‘Help us with this.’” It took some time for the board to realize that management was asking not for the answer but for engagement, he said, but “once they got used to it, it dramatically improved the board–management partnership and the value board members bring to the work of the company.”
The desire to create new and different ways of working is not always accompanied by the ability to do so, however. Adopting new roles and norms feels uncomfortable—even unnatural—to most people. To help address this knowing-doing gap, we spoke with directors and CEOs from a range of industries about their boards’ capacity to support innovation and risk management. The results were sobering, though the tide seems to be turning. A few of the directors in our study were clearly laggards, even going so far as to argue that innovation was irrelevant in their very mature industries. A handful were trailblazers, like Mark Ganz. The majority were just beginning to work their way through the challenges of governing innovation, some more deliberately and successfully than others.
Through our research, we identified the common obstacles most boards face and gleaned insight into how boards can reshape their roles to effectively foster and support the kind of innovation that leads to substantial growth.
Why Boards Struggle with Innovation
Boards increasingly believe that to fulfill their obligation to ensure the long-term well-being of their companies, they have to support management in developing a compelling innovation strategy. And that means learning to embrace risk while continuing to mitigate and manage it as much as possible. In this inverted risk paradigm, boards are discovering that avoiding risk is the riskiest proposition of all. Paula Price, a director at Accenture, Dollar General, and Western Digital Corporation, told us that boards should aim to develop the organization’s “capacity to pivot” into uncharted territory with new products, services, business models, or ways of organizing or getting work done. Standing still or waiting to see how things turn out are not considered serious options in today’s often tumultuous environment. A member of one automobile company’s board confessed that they had discouraged management from making the leap to electric cars for years; now he feared that the company was playing catch-up.
CEOs and top management appropriately have more power than board members over corporate affairs and major decisions. But without the full support of the board, management is unlikely to take the big bets required to innovate. What frustrations do board members report when asked about fulfilling their growing obligation to govern innovation? We found four main concerns:
An outdated innovation and risk agenda.
Most board members report that the lion’s share of their attention around innovation goes toward improving the organization’s capacity to execute its current strategy—that is, innovation to sustain the core: developing product line extensions, reducing cost structures to maintain healthy operating margins, improving customer-intimacy and -centricity to address rising customer expectations, and responding to new regulatory regimes and cybersecurity threats.
At the same time, these board members realize that doing the same things better, faster, and more cheaply is not enough. It is not enough, for instance, to make improvements that reduce costs in the supply chain. Companies are now trying to deploy digital supply chains that will allow them to offer different value propositions to customers and even create new business models. As one director put it, “Significant disruption is taking place, and whatever company is at the top today will not be at the top in 10 years. [We] must differentiate ourselves.” Another observed that his board’s “bias for short-term results” was stifling innovation; instead of pursuing breakthrough initiatives, the company was focused on evolutionary ones. Many directors acknowledged that it was not easy for CEOs to make the bold moves required to keep their companies competitive—especially given the growing demands of activist investors—and that boards were not doing enough to encourage management to pursue admittedly riskier initiatives that could reinvent the business.
Insufficient time.
Making time for innovation as an ongoing topic of boardroom conversation is a luxury few board members feel they have. Especially in industries undergoing regulatory changes, such as financial services, energy, and health care, directors reported feeling “overwhelmed” simply attending to the basics of compliance and financial monitoring. Even companies that were performing well struggled to dedicate time to innovation activities. Hasbro CEO Brian Goldner acknowledged the challenge: “It’s easy to focus only on the core business when it’s going great, but you have to find board time to focus on growth and disruptive activities.” Directors we spoke with understood the need to invest in strategic discussion and debate about innovation—as another CEO put it, “To think you can sit in the boardroom and talk strategy once a year means you’re out of the game and out to lunch”—yet competing pressures on their attention made it hard to find the time for proper consideration.
Lack of expertise.
Many directors—particularly CEOs—express frustration that their boards lack the level of industry expertise and innovation experience necessary to make well-informed risk-reward assessments about proposals. One CEO we spoke with said he actually avoided innovation discussions with the board because he believed that the directors “were too far from the market” to assess the true expected value of a particular innovation project.
Unproductive interactions between the board and management.
Historically, companies have maintained a bright line between the board of directors and senior management. Under this governance model, management’s role evolved into “telling and selling” strategy and the board’s role became to ratify the senior team’s vision. Many of the directors we spoke with consider these practices to be outdated; however, navigating new roles for the board and management in setting innovation strategy is proving to be the toughest challenge of all.
“Sometimes you need to create tension to stimulate thinking, ideas, and innovation.”
Many board members reported a reluctance to ask their most-pressing questions, because they don’t want to be perceived as “micromanaging” or “second-guessing management” or as criticizing the CEO in front of his or her team. Meanwhile, several CEOs told us that their boards’ arm’s-length behavior inhibited the understanding and support required to forge ahead and innovate. When boards do dig into the details of management’s innovation proposals, their tough questioning can sometimes be perceived as hostile. Several CEOs experienced such interactions as evaluative of their own performance rather than of the quality of the ideas under discussion, and many complained that the board’s responses can be “harsh” or “unfair.” In some of our interviews, we could see the emotional toll of these often-heated interactions on the faces of board members and CEOs.
(Re)Building the Board for Innovation
The research is clear: Innovation requires passionate discussion, debate, and even conflict—most often among individuals with diverse perspectives. To find better ways of governing innovation, more boards are revisiting both their board composition and the way in which they interact. However, directors are often reluctant to speak publicly—including to us—about how their boards operate, making it hard for boards to share best practices. This is especially problematic when it comes to innovation—an area where directors often feel there is work to be done. Our research revealed four key areas for improvement:
Diversity and collective literacy.
When adding or replacing members, boards should take a disciplined approach, seeking members whose expertise complements that of the existing board and, more important, that of management. For example, a director of a traditional operations-focused company reported seeking board members with experience leading exceptional customer-service-oriented companies. Tom Wilson, the CEO of Allstate, pointed out that it was a board member from the manufacturing sector working with OEMs and some of the hot start-ups in the connected car space who was able to offer unique insights into consumer behavior.
In addition, most board members we spoke with wanted more people with technology experience—so-called “digital directors.” They believed that directors from organizations reputed to be tech pioneers were likely to be more familiar with the challenges that come with doing innovative work and better prepared to offer informed advice on how to address them. They also wanted directors with the capacity to assess whether or not their companies were investing sufficiently in technology and associated talent.
To further bolster out-of-the-box thinking, a few boards are explicitly including intellectual or problem-solving diversity—difficult qualities to assess—in their composition matrices. Most directors we spoke with expressed concerns about whether their board composition was representative of their customers and stakeholders (with regard to factors such as gender, nationality, race, and ethnicity). And a handful of boards are making serious efforts to bring in younger-than-usual candidates, including Millennials, betting on potential rather than experience—a dramatic shift from the traditional approach.
For diverse individuals to collaborate effectively, they need shared experiences and knowledge to serve as a foundation for their interactions and decision making. Forward-thinking companies actively develop the collective literacy and contextual intelligence of the board—cultivating, in particular, a shared set of assumptions about where their industry and markets are going so that they are prepared to make the right risk/reward judgment calls together with management. Nearly half of the directors we spoke with bring in experts from different or adjacent industries to hold “master classes.” Some hold sessions with angel investors and venture capitalists to gain their industry insight. Others make visits to technology hubs such as Silicon Valley, accelerators in emerging markets, and companies and academic laboratories working on the cutting edge of a given area. A few told us they meet with key customers in small groups, while others say that their entire boards attend industry conferences together. Directors reported that all these activities prompt important discussions about their appetite for innovation by exposing them to “next practices,” not just best practices.
Creative abrasion.
This is the ability to develop a marketplace of ideas not from a single flash of insight but from a series of sparks generated through rigorous discourse and debate. Boards today recognize that creative abrasion is a core capability needed to engage in innovative problem-solving. One board member remarked, “Critical thinking is imperative, and that involves putting some friction into [the discussion] to fight the status quo.” Another stated, “Sometimes you need to create tension to stimulate thinking, ideas, and innovation.”
Indeed, the “mostly silent” board member is no longer seen as doing the job. The outspoken director once perceived as a “gadfly” is now accepted, even welcomed, in the boardroom. Boards need to learn to “tolerate some chaos” in meetings, according to one board member, if they expect management to engage in creative thinking. They must build a culture in which contrarian viewpoints are heard, even actively seeking directors with the “willingness and the dynamism to really mix it up in the boardroom,” as one CEO told us.
Virtual Idea Board
We weren’t surprised to hear that many boards are reluctant to have the frank conversations required for innovation because the dynamics of creative abrasion are so tough to manage. The default for many board members is to avoid conflict and become “too polite.” Facilitating creative abrasion is a delicate dance: Boards that are too supportive fail to sufficiently challenge proposals, but too much confrontation can stifle people’s willingness to offer ideas.
Redefining the partnership.
Balancing the board’s legal power and management’s executive power is not easy, but for innovation discussions to happen, neither side can dominate. Boards need to build a strong partnership with management and a sense of shared ownership of the innovation strategy. Allstate CEO Tom Wilson told us that unlike most boards, which meet to discuss strategy once a year, his board holds two separate strategy meetings: One is a dialogue about the company’s capabilities and market position and is focused on learning; the other is for decision making.
Directors say they are wary of CEOs who “play it safe.”
Some CEOs are getting more comfortable using the board as a thought partner. One described his board meetings now as “great idea-sparring sessions,” with a healthy degree of conflict and debate. As one of his board members admitted, she had to learn “how to have her nose in, but her fingers out.” Understandably, these sessions can be emotionally draining; some CEOs said they felt that their boards sometimes overstepped or “came on too strong.” The CEO of a Fortune 100 retailer told us, “I’ve learned from watching other CEOs and boards that if a board gets too far in the weeds, it is deadly.” Boards can avoid these issues by clarifying expectations at the outset.
Our research indicates that management teams are increasingly willing to make themselves vulnerable, embracing the board’s probing questions about their big-bet ideas and even discussing efforts that didn’t pan out. The more courageous CEOs we spoke with said they now seek more input from their board rather than less. One said he encourages dialogue with the board by asking management to share not only recommendations but also the other alternatives that were considered and rejected. Without this transparency, he explained, board members get frustrated and feel as though they are being “sold stuff” by management.
Getting to a place where management teams feel they can bring forward a portfolio of ideas, some of which are more developed than others, requires a real partnership mindset with boards—a shift in the conventional relationship between the two bodies. As former CEO of Mastercard Bob Selander told us, “Some people like to think that one big idea will lead to massive change, yet great boards recognize that it takes ongoing discussions about lots of ideas—the good and the bad—to produce breakthrough results.” For one CEO, this meant coaching his executives to expect and be open to hard questions and criticism, acknowledging that it’s not easy for his team to expose themselves (and their proposals) to negative reactions from individuals who often have less expertise about the matters at hand. “We had to be very explicit about saying, ‘We are not asking for your approval; we are still trying to figure this out,’” another CEO told us. Another said that trust was essential in building a collaborative mindset. “There’s a sense now that when we get done with a conversation, neither side feels beat up. Instead we feel like we got to a better decision.”
Encouraging risk and living with failure.
Supported Boards And Ides Certify
Boards know their companies must pursue not only incremental improvements but also breakthrough innovation. To foster both kinds of activity, they have to create a culture that is receptive to risk and the inevitable failure that comes with innovative problem solving. However, boards are not—and should not be—interested in innovating for innovation’s sake. To avoid innovation activity that doesn’t “move the needle,” CEOs and board members we spoke with focused on taking risks on efforts that were most likely to create shareholder value in the long term.
Determining whether an innovation at scale will be worth the investment is a very difficult proposition. One board member told us, “Discounted cash flow analyses won’t help us make a discussion about a breakthrough idea.” This is especially the case in large companies where, as one CEO observed, it is always difficult to make a significant impact on top-line growth.
Most board members in our study admit that they struggle with how to weigh shorter-term financial outcomes against other measures—such as customer-experience or market-share metrics, which might be better indicators of whether an innovation will bear fruit and improve the company’s competitive position in the long run. Rather than rely on outcome metrics, some boards are beginning to depend more on process measures when evaluating innovation initiatives. For example, one board member said that he frequently asked his team what the company was learning about its customers as it experimented. In some cases, boards also track vitality indices—the percentage of total revenue that comes from new products and services—to measure the organization’s innovation capacity as a whole.
We know from a deep body of research that many—even most—innovation efforts fail. So boards must learn to recognize when an initiative should be abandoned. A number of board members said they wanted their companies to figure out how to “fail fast and learn fast” so that they can get on with other endeavors. Some directors said they now make sure to state aloud in board meetings that some innovation efforts should be expected to fail. Although none of the board members we interviewed reported having discussions about the difference between “praiseworthy” and “blameworthy” failures, as Harvard Business School professor Amy Edmondson calls them, they recognize that you can’t plan your way to an innovation, you have to act your way there, and that there are bound to be missteps along the way. Indeed, board members say they are wary of CEOs who “play it safe,” as one described. A sizable number of the search committee chairs we spoke with said they are skeptical of executive candidates who have never experienced failure and look for potential CEO successors to show, as another director said, “stretch efforts that included missteps and learning from them.”
CONCLUSION
Governing innovation is not for the faint of heart. The journey takes time and determination. It takes the courage to act in the long-term interests of the organization even when markets are more short-sighted. It takes the determination to fight the natural human aversion to risk and the fortitude to engage in creative abrasion.
Supported Boards And Ides Unemployment
Balancing power between the board and management has never been easy, but our study suggests that as more boards are embracing new norms, a new contract between boards and management is emerging, making it possible, at last, for directors and CEOs to work together to support and facilitate innovation.